Simon & Garfunkel have two three-CD box sets collecting their entire career output, one with out-takes and live recordings, but the duo who were among the bestselling acts of the 1960s only recorded five studio albums throughout the entire 1960s! Their studio perfectionism is never better served than here. This greatest hits is simple and to the point, a perfect collection for anyone looking to get the basic idea (and hits) without committing to a more serious relationship. The harmonies, Paul Simon's masterful songwriting, Garfunkel's soaring choirboy voice, are all here. --Rob O'Connor

It would be churlish to criticize "Greatest Hits", as it's the classic compilation, and the best possible 40-odd minute introduction to the duo's work. On the face of it, everything's here. Plus this is an of-the-time release, one you or your parents probably owned way-back-when, and even the cover can bring on pangs of nostalgia. It's still a superb listen and, even if like me you own all the original albums, it's something that is always first to get in the player. Sometimes I don't even stop it before "Cecilia" -- and not just because I'm not quick enough having been lulled into a pleasurable stupor by the "Bookends" coda.

BUT this is what you must know. A number of these songs are NOT the original studio versions, they're live recordings. This album was not released to celebrate the duo's career, it was released to commemorate a brief reunion in 1972 when they played a concert tour. The company rushed out the album in 1972 to cash in on the reunion. That's why you have the lovely moustached Simon on the front. Rather than just package all the hits, which the fans would already have (they only split up a year or so previous), they threw in a bunch of live recordings which made it a must-have for the completists (and still does). "Emily", "Feelin' Groovy", "Homeward Bound" and "Kathy's Song" are all live versions. They sound lovely, but they're not the original album versions.

Also, you might want to be aware that, in the spirit of the day, the introductions to both "Sound of Silence" and "Bridge over Troubled Water" overlap with the live audience applause, which may have been to attempt to blur the boundaries between the live stuff and the studio stuff. It's not clean. We're not talking a "Shaved Fish" hatchet job here, but it might just annoy you enough to wish you'd bought one of the more recent compilations.

Where and when were the live tracks recorded? I have no idea. Possibly during the reunion, but I'd love to think they were 60s vintage. I'd also wish the company could dig out the entire concert and release that -- where there's some, there must be more.

My personal advice is: buy this one. You know you'll buy all the original albums anyway, and there's nowhere else you can hear all the live stuff here. Plus, it's such a cool album, with such strong memories attached. Even if the CD presentation is cheap and lacks any informative liner notes (or tells you some of the tracks are live) whatsoever.

This is a good collection of Simon & Garfunkel's wonderful work, and a good place to start if unfamiliar with their music. However, I prefer their double disc 'Tales From New York'. That collection expands on what is here, particularly including some of their important early stuff, and is a better representation of the diversity of their music.

This is a diamond of an album! Some of the songs must have been composed from an alternate world;a world that reflects our inner desires, and one that plucks our heart strings once melodies such as "Emily", "Sound of Silence" and Bridge of Troubled Water. There are no bad or even averagesongs in this album and if I could give six stars,I wouldn't hesitate to do so.

I like Simon And Garfunkel, they are my favourite old band in the sixties and seventies.

59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy)
# Hello Lamppost #- reminds me of Lady And The Tramp cartoon film.
# The Boxer #- lie-la-lie #- reminds me of Lady And The Tramp too.

H'mm....first bought this album in the mid-seventies.Its a fine intro' to the huge talent of Simon and Garfunkel.The tracks are gleaned from four of their five original albums and as such are a fair sample of those original albums.That said this is still only a sample and there are many fine songs not included here.Still this album contains all their major hits, from their first 'Sounds of Silence' right through to 'Bridge' and 'The Boxer' off their last album.It gives a good cross section of the different type of songs that Simon was so good at creating.From the isolationist 'I Am A Rock' to the merry 'Cecilia'(a plea to St.Cecilia-patron saint of music to come back and assist in the writing of more music), this album covers all moods.There is not one bad track here but mention must be made of the beautiful 'America' and the smash hit 'Mrs Robinson', both taken off the classic album 'Bookends'.
If you enjoy this you should buy the original albums as they are all excellent, even the neglected 'Wednesday Morning 3A.M.'.
Yes a good intro' to their music and excellent value at this price.Buy and enjoy...you can't go wrong!!